Identity verification can be necessary when we transfer money or use a government service. But if our real identities also have to be traceable when we leave a comment, join a forum or publish an article, what remains of our freedom to speak? In George Orwell’s 1984, a device called the telescreen kept everyone under watch. Iran’s parliament appears to be pursuing a nationwide telescreen of its own. This article examines what it would mean for the country if digital freedom ceased to have any meaning.
From the “Protection Bill” to Platform Regulation
In 2021, the proposal known as the “Protection Bill” sparked debate over restrictions on access to online services, rules governing tools that bypass internet filtering, and the role of security agencies in managing the internet. The “Cyberspace Regulation Bill” was formally received by Iran’s parliament on 3 August 2025. This article focuses on the eight-article draft that reached the media in late August 2026.
The draft gives the Supreme Council of Cyberspace a central role in policymaking and places much of the responsibility for implementing the rules on service providers. Article 5 treats failure to verify users’ identities before providing a service, in accordance with the “Trusted Identity System”, as a breach. Proposed penalties include fines of 1 to 10 per cent of annual revenue, restrictions on taking on new users, and suspension or revocation of licences. A three-member panel would hear cases in the first instance, with its decisions subject to appeal before the Administrative Justice Court. Analysis of the draft and Article 5
What Does Online Anonymity Protect?
The Supreme Council of Cyberspace adopted the “Trusted Identity System in the Country’s Cyberspace” on 31 August 2019. Article 3(6) sets out the principle that every interaction in Iran’s cyberspace should be traceable, directly or indirectly, to an identifiable person. Readers might see only an author’s pseudonym, yet linking identifiers could still reveal who wrote the piece. Text of the 2019 resolution (Persian)
The practical questions are what information each service collects, who can link those identifiers, and how long the data is kept. An employee writing about working conditions or a citizen asking about a sensitive issue may decide to stay silent for fear of being identified. That chilling effect can arise before any official action is taken.
The Cost of Unclear Rules for Businesses
Identity verification requires technical infrastructure, data protection and a way to resolve errors. A fine calculated on annual revenue can weigh heavily on a business with a narrow profit margin. If the scope of the obligation remains unclear, companies may collect more information or make their services harder to access to reduce the risk of a fine.
Article 7 of the draft provides for public consultation on certain decisions. Its value depends on publishing proposals in good time, giving people enough time to respond and explaining how their comments are considered. The more detail that is left to future regulations, the more important that transparency becomes for users and businesses.
How Do the European Union, the United States and China Approach This?
European Union. The General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) requires personal data to be limited to what is necessary for the purpose for which it is processed. Processing must also have a lawful basis. When an organisation verifies identity, these principles govern what it can collect and for what purpose. Articles 5 and 6 of the GDPR
United States. In McIntyre v. Ohio Elections Commission, the Supreme Court held that a ban on distributing anonymous election leaflets violated the First Amendment. The ruling illustrates how anonymous political speech can be protected from government-mandated identification. The scope of that protection depends on the type of speech and the regulation at issue. Read the McIntyre decision
China. China’s Cybersecurity Law requires real identity information for services such as network access, instant messaging and publishing information. Alongside internet restrictions, China has widely used domestic services such as WeChat and Alibaba. For a business in Iran that depends on overseas customers or tools, a domestic service may do little to offset the cost of losing access to the global internet. English translation of China’s Cybersecurity Law
What Are We Protecting?
Every identity verification requirement should answer a few questions. What specific risk does it reduce? Could the same goal be achieved with less data? Who oversees access to the information, and how can users challenge a decision? Clear answers are part of protecting citizens’ rights. The internet’s value to society also depends on whether people can read, ask questions and write without fearing identification and its consequences.
The Islamic Republic appears intent on closing off every remaining avenue for digital freedom in the name of security, so that it can monitor citizens individually and silence critics. If the bill passes and, more importantly, can be put into practice, Orwell’s telescreen will have moved from fiction into reality.